Re: BOB'S BITS
Posted: 22 May 2026, 14:55
DOYLE
When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth. Sherlock Holmes, in several instances, but first in The Sign of the Four(1890) by Arthur Conan Doyle.
One would not want to question Sherlock Holmes’s reputation as a paragon of deductive rationality, but this is surely dangerous advice. The more prudent course would be to say, ‘at this point, you need to conduct new experiments.’ And it’s worth pointing out, coincidentally, that by 1890 Arthur Conan Doyle was already taking great interest in ‘spiritualism,’ in that wondrous hybrid of Victorian hopes and fears that led many people to believe that could one get beyond the material world there would still be much to discover. Holmes’s fascination with that other universe of possibilities continued to intensify and became obsessive. By the time Holmes himself ‘passed’, in 1930, this eccentricity was one of the most remarkable things about him. Thus the New York Times’ 1930 obit on Doyle begins with and keeps returning to his deep interest in other-worldly phenomena. In the obit, Sherlock Holmes gets much less space and the infinitely amenable Dr. Watson and the supernaturally malevolent Moriarty rate no mention whatsoever. So much for obituarists, one might well conclude. Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of the world’s most famous detective (Holmes) and the world’s most consummate villain (Moriarty) was born on May 22, 1859, in Edinburgh. His father and grandfather encouraged him in artistic pursuits, which eventually won out although a passel of rich uncles tried to educate him into a medical career at Stonyhurst and the University of Edinburgh. And indeed Doyle did doctor, at first, but in the intervals between patients he sketched out mystery stories. His first big success (£25!!!) was published in 1888, and very shortly thereafter Holmes, Watson, and Moriarty (and speckled bands and silent hounds) started to disturb the slumbers of the reading public in Britain, America, and beyond. There are many interesting aspects to the Holmes-Doyle saga, but spiritualism and psychic research? These became obsessions after Doyle’s son, Kingsley, died in 1918. Doyle spent the rest of his life and much of his fortune promoting psychic research and psychic stories. It worked in the limited sense that after his death his family expected to hear from him momentarily. And they followed his spiritualist wish to be buried in a standing position, just in case. The local parish church wouldn’t have it (and, anyway, regarded Doyle as a non-believer), so he was buried upright in the garden of his mansion house. Given time, however, the Church of England can forgive almost anything. In 1955, Doyle vertical was disinterred and reburied as Doyle horizontal, next to his second wife, Jean, in All Saints churchyard, Minstead. Myself, I think it’s better to remember Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (MD Edinburgh) as a stout advocate of vaccination, indubitably a this-world medicine. ©
When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth. Sherlock Holmes, in several instances, but first in The Sign of the Four(1890) by Arthur Conan Doyle.
One would not want to question Sherlock Holmes’s reputation as a paragon of deductive rationality, but this is surely dangerous advice. The more prudent course would be to say, ‘at this point, you need to conduct new experiments.’ And it’s worth pointing out, coincidentally, that by 1890 Arthur Conan Doyle was already taking great interest in ‘spiritualism,’ in that wondrous hybrid of Victorian hopes and fears that led many people to believe that could one get beyond the material world there would still be much to discover. Holmes’s fascination with that other universe of possibilities continued to intensify and became obsessive. By the time Holmes himself ‘passed’, in 1930, this eccentricity was one of the most remarkable things about him. Thus the New York Times’ 1930 obit on Doyle begins with and keeps returning to his deep interest in other-worldly phenomena. In the obit, Sherlock Holmes gets much less space and the infinitely amenable Dr. Watson and the supernaturally malevolent Moriarty rate no mention whatsoever. So much for obituarists, one might well conclude. Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of the world’s most famous detective (Holmes) and the world’s most consummate villain (Moriarty) was born on May 22, 1859, in Edinburgh. His father and grandfather encouraged him in artistic pursuits, which eventually won out although a passel of rich uncles tried to educate him into a medical career at Stonyhurst and the University of Edinburgh. And indeed Doyle did doctor, at first, but in the intervals between patients he sketched out mystery stories. His first big success (£25!!!) was published in 1888, and very shortly thereafter Holmes, Watson, and Moriarty (and speckled bands and silent hounds) started to disturb the slumbers of the reading public in Britain, America, and beyond. There are many interesting aspects to the Holmes-Doyle saga, but spiritualism and psychic research? These became obsessions after Doyle’s son, Kingsley, died in 1918. Doyle spent the rest of his life and much of his fortune promoting psychic research and psychic stories. It worked in the limited sense that after his death his family expected to hear from him momentarily. And they followed his spiritualist wish to be buried in a standing position, just in case. The local parish church wouldn’t have it (and, anyway, regarded Doyle as a non-believer), so he was buried upright in the garden of his mansion house. Given time, however, the Church of England can forgive almost anything. In 1955, Doyle vertical was disinterred and reburied as Doyle horizontal, next to his second wife, Jean, in All Saints churchyard, Minstead. Myself, I think it’s better to remember Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (MD Edinburgh) as a stout advocate of vaccination, indubitably a this-world medicine. ©